« Bloggy Goodness Map.. | Main | Supernatural Revelation »

Danger: Anti-Missionary Attack Will Be Found Here!

Posted on Monday, October 10, 2005 at 15:54 by Registered Commenterdaycruz in | Comments21 Comments | References1 Reference

Like most Desi bloggers, I always peruse through the many different posts on Sepia Mutiny. I might even buy a t-shirt at some point. A lot of times, I get struck by the ferocity with which Anti-Christian commentors attack me. Well it hasn't happend a lot (or ever before), but it has happend today with Mutineer Manish's post on Harriet Miers has sparked a huge debate about Christanity and "spreading the gospel" as us Jesus Freaks like to call it. Here's what he wrote:

 The Central India Christian Mission is part of the Texan-xtian nexus:

The primary task of the mission is evangelism and church planting… It is the need of the hour to train the native leaders in India as much as possible. The Mission Center… is located on about 15 acres of land in Damoh District of Central Province [Madhya Pradesh], India. [Link]

The missionaries, Indu and Ajai Lall and their Bible college-trained brood, are apparently the Johnny Appleseeds of Indian churches:

Over 400 churches have been planted in central and northern India, in the country of Nepal and along the northeast India/Bhutan border. [Link - PDF]

  This has made a lot of people angry: there are a lot of comments floating around, but the basic idea is that Christians should just shut up and enjoy their salvation by themselves and not bring any one else into it. So here is what I posted:

 

Ok, it has come for me to voice my opinion on this. As a Pentecostal Christian Keralite out of India now currently residing in the United States. Those of you on this blog have made some serious unfair statements about Christians and Christian missionaries. As I am related to several missionaries. (Two uncles are pastors, another one goes on missions to Africa) It certainly hurts when I hear people making suggestions that they could be exploiting people. I know, that in the same sense that I couldn't make a blanket statement about all missionaries that they are all bad. I couldn't do the same that they are all good. But I have met several missionaries who sincerely care about these people. They care about the poor people in India, and those that suffer. And as Razib said, as Christians we believe the only way to heaven is through Jesus Christ. Thus, there are missionaries working among the rich and poor of India spreading the gospel, because we have a burden for the lost. I understand that sounds demeaning to a lot of people. But I am sincere when I say that it is not meant to be. I can not speak for all Christians, I can speak for the ones I've met and talked to. We care deeply about our Indian brothers and sisters. I hope to see all of them in Heaven once I die. Thus I tell them about the love of Jesus Christ. I don't want their money or anything else. I don't know what else to say, I'm just trying to defend the missionaries, I guess. Please, take a look at the other side before attacking Christians in India and other countries around the globe.

Oh and to the first commenter. What the Spanish did was not at all the right way. If you spread the gospel according to the Bible, you will not be exploiting people or enslaving them. Have a good day folks, and may God richly bless you.

I had already marked myself as a Pentecostal Malayalee. Here is what happend next:

Daycruz,
Would you plz keep your Love of God in your Christian Blog. I believe you misunderstood this blog as a place to preach.

I have a small advice for you. Before you take others burden on yourself, just worry about your burden. That may lead you to hell or heaven or whatever you believe in. Dont forget that you live in a capitalistic society. First worry about your ass, then you can worry about other's ass.

I will never ever believe someone who says he is carrying someone else burden on himself for the sake of going to heaven. Its Just plain bull****.

By the way, is hell really that bad? ...not my HFO

 And so there. A whole can of worms got opened up. A lot of argument stems from this misconception that all Missionaries are attempting to bribe the lower-caste Hindus into becoming Christians by providing them with food and shelter. Well, here's my take: this sort of argument seems flawed to me because it denys the Dalits any sort of choice on how they wish to live their lives. It denys them a conscience by telling them that if they choose to become Christians they are just being bribed and not making a rational decision. It also makes a blanket statement of all missionaries. Not all missionaries are good and neither are all bad. There is always a mix. The missionaries that I have dealt with are wonderful people and really do care about the lost in India. Another thing is, how can Christianity really be Christianity unless I tell others about Christ. For isn't it in the great commision? The idea that we go out and preach the gospel to all nations? The discussion has gotten so vast that it's hard for me to keep track of who's saying what but go there and take a look and tell me what you think.

EmailEmail Article to Friend

References (1)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.

Reader Comments (21)

Daycruz,
Don't let these people bring you down. Their time will come, "every knee shall bow, and every tongue shall confess that Jesus Christ is Lord"
God has not called us to be closet Christians, you tell them Monay, that "greater is He that is in me, than that is in the world". We do not want to fight verbally with them, they are really misinformed. I'm sure God is already dealing with some of them. I know we should not make this a big deal, but Daycruz I will stand by you if you need any help or support, spiritually that is.

Your brother in the Lord
Pastor S. Thomas
10.10.2005 | Unregistered CommenterPastor S. Thomas
well, i generally agreed with your take over their, but i hope they don't read your pastor declaring that "God is already dealing with some of them," that will just feed paranoia. in any case, i think a big problem is cultural. i'm an atheist and i don't care you talking about your religion and stuff, but i'm also an american and used to that sort of chatter. i think a lot of them are transferring an indian (hindu) sensibility as regards the permissibility of religious chatter (comportment, etc.), and refuse to acknowledge your point of view. if india was as prosperous as the west of course it would obviate a lot of the pent up resentment.
10.10.2005 | Unregistered Commenterrazib_the_atheist
p.s. i suspect on reason i can see your point of view is we both reject the hindu tendency toward accepting all paths to god as equally relevant and real. you accept only one path. i accept one less (i.e.; none).
10.10.2005 | Unregistered Commenterrazib_the_atheist
Razib, I agree. Our pastor is just a tad bit old school but he doesn't mean deal in the sense we mean. Oh heck I don't even know why I'm explaining it. Thanks for the visit and the comments. I enjoy your writing btw.
10.10.2005 | Unregistered Commenterdaycruz
np, northwestern brownz need to stick together against the city slickers :)

peace
10.10.2005 | Unregistered Commenterrazib_the_atheist
good ! keep standing firm for God Daycruz! Rock on!
10.10.2005 | Unregistered Commenter~SIM J~
i can't believe i said ROCK ON....terribly sory bout that..lol
10.10.2005 | Unregistered Commenter~SIM J~
Sorry for the poor choice for words.
You are correct Razib, forgive me, what I meant by "dealing" was not that God was going to punish them, just simply create circumstances where they will rethink what they said.
I read the comments, it's just a person who has some inaccurate information about both both Christianity and the Indian culture.

Your humble brother,
Pastor S. Thomas
10.11.2005 | Unregistered CommenterPastor S. Thomas
Hi daycruz. I think that you stated your opinions respectfully. If some people feel the need to attack you personally for that, that's really poor form!
10.11.2005 | Unregistered CommenterJay
u now hav a fan club at SM ... i told u im not gud at words ... well atleast i tried to continue on the same line as yours there ... i was just about to reply again ... and they closed the post section!

hopefully we'll go at it again some other time ... when i get a bit more free time at work =P
10.11.2005 | Unregistered Commenterbig bj
the terrorists are also fueled by a deep anti christian/jewish hatred ... it's so destructive

10.11.2005 | Unregistered Commenterisaac
What terrorists? Are terrorists blogging yet?
i thought i'd add to the surreal comment...
but somebody please explain how that comment relates to this post. get creative if you want...
10.13.2005 | Unregistered Commenterzimblymallu
think zimbly, ..think really hard, ..chew on the cud
10.13.2005 | Unregistered Commenterisaac
Hey Issac,

After "chewing on...cud" like you suggested-- I still don't exactly understand where your going with that statement.

Issac: "the terrorists are also fueled by a deep anti christian/jewish hatred ... it's so destructive."


-- you may need clarify your statements, your comment if taken the wrong way can start an online war between two weblogs. I believe what you said was a slip of the tongue.

btw-- chewin' on cud isn't so bad have you tried it? like u suggested it helps you think better-- while your at it chew on a big piece!)



-Engima
10.15.2005 | Unregistered CommenterEnigma
De Cruz,

You never cease to amaze me. "Noice" job =) I"m gonna follow your lead-- ;)

God bless.
10.15.2005 | Unregistered CommenterEnigma
what? now there's going to be a war?
10.15.2005 | Registered Commenterzimblymallu
is everything an enigma for you, enigma?
10.15.2005 | Unregistered Commenterisaac
i'm not aware of the drama behind the scenes of the weblogs you mentioned, ..sorry if i've offended
10.15.2005 | Unregistered Commenterisaac
which weblogs? what drama? am i losing my mind?

*music plays* welcome to the twilight zone...
suddenly a voice.
Yesuvinte namathil. PHO Pizhashay.

we see the preemptive sorry and strike back with a preemptive "it was not my wish to cause any bad feelings on this blog"
anybody else want to get in on the healing power of forgiveness?
10.15.2005 | Registered Commenterzimblymallu
lol
10.15.2005 | Unregistered Commenterisaac

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.